Magistrate Judge Thomas Hixson has ordered the criminal enterprise formerly known as Facebook™ to tell him who was involved in ordering the torrenting of pirated works in order to train their AI.
If I had a guess, my guess would be that their name rhymes with Lark Buckerberg.
Meta will have to name the people who greenlit its torrenting of pirated books. A federal magistrate judge has ordered the company to identify everyone who approved sourcing books from LibGen and Anna’s Archive. This goes beyond the employees who ran the downloads and includes whoever decided whether to seed the books to others.
Last month, Magistrate Judge Thomas Hixson ordered Meta to hand over the command histories of the servers it used to torrent pirated books.
………
The server logs could reveal what happened on Meta’s machines. However, publisher Entrepreneur Media also wants to know who approved the torrenting activity.
Entrepreneur Media, which publishes Entrepreneur magazine, filed one of the related lawsuits where it accuses Meta of contributing to piracy by uploading (seeding) works to third parties, similar to the authors’ contributory infringement claim.
To find out more, the publisher asked Meta to identify everyone who “made, authorized, or approved” the decisions to obtain the shadow library datasets, and to do so via BitTorrent.
Meta’s answers named several people who are believed to have been involved in data-related decisions. However, Meta said it couldn’t identify anyone who “formally” made or approved decisions to acquire or use books for its first two Llama models. Those decisions were often the result of team consensus, Meta argued.
When it came to the torrenting itself, Meta pointed to the employees who ran the downloads, describing their choices as technical decisions.
………
Meta added that the acquisition of data from Anna’s Archive went through an internal legal review in early 2024, which involved its in-house lawyers.
That bit about, "Technical Decisions, "is bullsh%$. It does not go through legal unless someone senior approving this whole scheme.
While seeing Mark Zuckerberg frog-marched out of his office in handcuffs over something as prosaic as this would be a bit disappointing, they got Al Capone for tax evasion.
There is precedent.








