Showing posts sorted by relevance for query excess deaths. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query excess deaths. Sort by date Show all posts

25 February 2024

I've Been Saying This Since

In March of 2020, I made a (pretty lame) attempt to use excess death rates to see the potential effects of Covid-19.

I have been suggesting that Covid mortality is under reported since May of 2020 using excess death rates.

Well, it's now in a peer reviewed paper:

Nearly 1,170,000 people have died from COVID-19 in the United States according to official federal counts, but multiple excess mortality studies suggest that these totals are vastly undercounted. While excess mortality provides an estimation of deaths that likely would not have occurred under normal, non-pandemic conditions, there is still little evidence into whether the SARS-CoV-2 virus contributed to these additional deaths, or whether these deaths were caused by other factors such as healthcare disruptions or socioeconomic challenges.

Now, a new study led by Boston University School of Public Health (BUSPH) and the University of Pennsylvania (UPenn) provides the first concrete data showing that many of these excess deaths were indeed uncounted COVID-19 deaths.

Published in the journal PNAS, the study compared reported COVID-19 deaths to excess deaths due to non-COVID, natural causes, such as diseases and chronic illnesses, and found that increases in non-COVID excess deaths occurred at the same time or in the month prior to increases in reported COVID-19 deaths in most US counties.

Focusing on excess deaths by natural causes rather than all-cause excess death estimates provides a more accurate understanding of the true number of deaths attributable to COVID-19, as it eliminates external causes for mortality, such as intentional or unintentional injuries, for which COVID-19 would not be a contributing factor.

"Our findings show that many COVID-19 deaths went uncounted during the pandemic. Surprisingly, these undercounts persisted well beyond the initial phase of the pandemic," says study corresponding author Dr. Andrew Stokes, associate professor of global health at BUSPH, who has led numerous studies analyzing excess mortality patterns and drivers during the pandemic.

A note here, the language seems to imply that the pandemic is an artifact of the past.  It ain't.

We are still suffering from the pandemic, and just reported Covid deaths appear to be remaining over 1,000 a week.

Finally, wear your f%$#ing mask.

28 March 2020

Oh Sh%$

Italy is one of the countries hardest hit by the corona virus.

One of the hardest hit cities in Italy is Nembro.

Now the Mayor of Nembro and the CEO of a chain of Italian clinic have done an analysis of excess deaths indicating that in Italy, where testing and reporting is FAR more extensive than in the US, deaths from Covid-19 are at least 4 times more than reported.

It should be noted that in unsettled situations like wars and plagues, excess deaths is the generally the best way to get accurate numbers:
Nembro, one of the municipalities most affected by Covid-19, should have had - under normal conditions - about 35 deaths. 158 people were registered dead this year by the municipal offices. But the number of deaths officially attributed to Covid-19 is 31.

In Nembro the almost deserted streets, the absent traffic, a strange silence is sometimes interrupted by the siren of an ambulance that carries with it the anxiety and worry that fill the hearts of all in these weeks. In Nembro every member of the community continuously receives news that he never wanted to hear, every day we lose people who were part of our lives and our community. Nembro, in the province of Bergamo, is the municipality most affected by Covid-19 in relation to the population. We do not know exactly how many people have been infected, but we know that the number of deaths officially attributed to Covid-19 is 31. We are two physicists: one who became an entrepreneur in the health sector, the other a mayor, in close contact with a very cohesive territory, where we know each other very well. We noticed that something in these official numbers did not come back right, and we decided - together - to check. We looked at the average of the deaths in the municipality of previous years, in the period January - March. Nembro should have had - under normal conditions - about 35 deaths. 158 people were registered dead this year by the municipal offices. That is 123 more than the average. Not 31 more, as it should have been according to the official numbers of the coronavirus epidemic.

The difference is enormous and cannot be a simple statistical deviation. Demographic statistics have their «constancies» and annual averages change only when completely «new» phenomena arrive. In this case, the number of abnormal deaths compared to the average that Nembro recorded in the period of time in consideration is equal to 4 times those officially attributed to Covid-19. If a comparison is made between the deaths that have occurred and the same period in previous years, the anomaly is even more evident: there is a peak of «other» deaths in correspondence with that of the official deaths from Covid-19.
It may be that some of these from other causes that occurred because of an overloaded healthcare system, but the overwhelming majority of those excess deaths are from Covid-19.

These numbers also set the fatality rate at an absolute minimum of 1%.

Not good.

12 March 2022

Sounds Right

Based on excess death statistics, I have been asserting that the actual Covid-19 death rate is far higher than what has been reported,  I suggested that deaths were approaching 1½ million in July in July of last year.

Well, now The Lancet will be publishing an article which concludes that Covid mortality is 3 times what was reported:

Although reported COVID-19 deaths between Jan 1, 2020, and Dec 31, 2021, totalled 5·94 million worldwide, we estimate that 18·2 million (95% uncertainty interval 17·1–19·6) people died worldwide because of the COVID-19 pandemic (as measured by excess mortality) over that period. The global all-age rate of excess mortality due to the COVID-19 pandemic was 120·3 deaths (113·1–129·3) per 100 000 of the population, and excess mortality rate exceeded 300 deaths per 100 000 of the population in 21 countries. The number of excess deaths due to COVID-19 was largest in the regions of south Asia, north Africa and the Middle East, and eastern Europe. At the country level, the highest numbers of cumulative excess deaths due to COVID-19 were estimated in India (4·07 million [3·71–4·36]), the USA (1·13 million [1·08–1·18]), Russia (1·07 million [1·06–1·08]), Mexico (798 000 [741 000–867 000]), Brazil (792 000 [730 000–847 000]), Indonesia (736 000 [594 000–955 000]), and Pakistan (664 000 [498 000–847 000]). Among these countries, the excess mortality rate was highest in Russia (374·6 deaths [369·7–378·4] per 100 000) and Mexico (325·1 [301·6–353·3] per 100 000), and was similar in Brazil (186·9 [172·2–199·8] per 100 000) and the USA (179·3 [170·7–187·5] per 100 000).
On a per capita basis, this is still ⅛ that of the Spanish Influenza outbreak, but it's pretty grim.

It also indicates that a number of actions, such as not instituting compulsory licensing of vaccines, were profoundly misguided.

19 May 2020

Finally, CDC Excess Death Data


Excess Deaths Chart Porn
Here.

I have been saying for some time that the best metric for Covid-19 deaths is excess deaths, which is made from counting total deaths, and comparing to historical data to show how many deaths might result from a particular massive disaster.

You can go to the link, and get excess death numbers, generate charts, and download the underlying data.

The data is incomplete, but what they have so far shows at least 65K excess deaths from mid-march through out the end of April.

This number is likely to increase as more death data makes its way to the CDC.

26 April 2021

The New York Times Catches Up With Me


Worse than Spanish Influenza

I've been talking about how excess deaths is the best measure of Covid-19 mortality, (see here and here) and now the New York Times has discovered the statistical measure.

It only took them a year, though the graph surprised me.

It turns out that Covid is worse than the Spanish Influenza epidemic: 

A surge in deaths from the Covid-19 pandemic created the largest gap between the actual and expected death rate in 2020 — what epidemiologists call “excess deaths,” or deaths above normal.

Aside from fatalities directly attributed to Covid-19, some excess deaths last year were most likely undercounts of the virus or misdiagnoses, or indirectly related to the pandemic otherwise. Preliminary federal data show that overdose deaths have also surged during the pandemic.

………

In 2020, however, the United States saw the largest single-year surge in the death rate since federal statistics became available. The rate increased 16 percent from 2019, even more than the 12 percent jump during the 1918 flu pandemic.

These numbers are really f%$#ing scary.

21 July 2021

Under Counts are the Rule, not the Exception

The US statistics currently show about 625 thousand deaths from Covid 19, but the excess death data shows about twice that, with CDC excess death data, showing between 1.23 and 1.52 million deaths.

Of course some of these deaths did not come from Covid, there was a surge in opioid deaths, and there may have been deaths from deferred medical care, but an under count of 50% does seem to be a good rough guess.

In India, it looks like they under counted Covid deaths by something approaching 90%.

This is not a surprise.  It is clear that the Modi government is doing its best to lie itself out of its disastrous management of the pandemic. 

But these sorts of demographics are much harder to fudge than official government death counts:

The number of people who have died in the coronavirus pandemic in India so far is likely to exceed three million — nearly 10 times the official Covid-19 death toll — making it one of the worst human tragedies in the nation’s history, according to a new study.

In a comprehensive examination of the true toll of the pandemic in the sprawling nation of 1.4 billion, the Center for Global Development, a Washington research institute, attempted to quantify excess deaths from all causes during the pandemic based on state data, international estimates, serological studies and household surveys.

“True deaths are likely to be in the several millions, not hundreds of thousands, making this arguably India’s worst human tragedy,” said its authors, one of whom is a former chief economic adviser to the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

The official government numbers have been called into question repeatedly. Even as funeral pyres lit up the night sky and bodies washed up on the Ganges River, with death all around, the Indian government was widely underreporting the scale of the devastation.

………

The study released on Tuesday estimated that between 3.4 and 4.7 million more people than would normally be expected died between January 2020 and June 2021, and includes an estimate suggesting that deaths from Covid-19 alone may have reached four million.

“Estimating Covid deaths with statistical confidence may prove elusive,” the authors wrote. “But all estimates suggest that the death toll from the pandemic is likely to be an order of magnitude greater than the official count of 400,000; they also suggest that the first wave was more lethal than is believed.”

These numbers are incredibly grim.

07 May 2021

I've Been Saying this for HOW Long?

As I have been saying for a while, it has been obvious to anyone watching excess deaths data that Covid-19 deaths are at least 50% higher than reported. 

It appears that the University of Washington's University of Washington’s Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME) has come to the same conclusion, though their number is about 100% more than reported, or about 6.9 million deaths with a total world population of about 7.88 billion.

By way of comparison, the death toll from Spanish Influenza was somewhere between 20 and 50 million with a population of 1.80 billion.

A new analysis of the toll of the Covid-19 pandemic suggests 6.9 million people worldwide have died from the disease, more than twice as many people as has been officially reported, with the under reporting being highest in less developed nations.

The numbers are grim:

In the United States, the analysis estimates, 905,000 people have died of Covid since the start of the pandemic. That is about 61% higher than the current death estimate from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 561,594. The new figure also surpasses the estimated number of U.S. deaths in the 1918 flu pandemic, which was estimated to have killed approximately 675,000 Americans.

The analysis was conducted by scientists at the University of Washington’s Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation.

“We’re probably not yet at the global toll of Spanish flu and certainly not at the death rate from Spanish flu. But given what’s unfolding in India right now, given our expectation of continued deaths, Covid is going to rival Spanish flu at the global level in terms of the count, likely, before we see the end of this epidemic,” the institute’s director, Christopher Murray, told reporters in a briefing.

………

The estimates are of deaths directly related to Covid, and do not include deaths that resulted from the pandemic’s disruption of health care — for example, people who did not seek care for heart attacks because they were afraid to go to Covid-swamped hospitals.

You can find the study here.

It's a lot worse than the official numbers.
 

20 March 2023

It was 20 Years Ago Today

I don't mean this:


I mean this, the start of the US invasion of Iraq:

So, after 4,500 military deaths,about 500 mercenary deaths, and a death toll of between 151,000 and 1,033,000 Iraqis.  (I lean toward the latter number, excess deaths are generally more accurate statistic, and BTW, that is nearly 4% of Iraq's population) 

All of this because ……… We've never really have never told the truth.

Why Bush, Cheney, Rice, Bremer, etc. have never been charged with crimes against humanity by the Hague is beyond me.

I know that these warrants would never been enforced, but at the very least they have second thoughts before traveling overseas.

The fact that they will end up dying of natural causes is an absolute travesty.

Note that despite the fact that Saddam Hussein was a despot, (apart from that Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play) it was a functioning society with free education, free healthcare, and relatively low levels of violence. (Except for the murderous secret police)

It would have been possible to remove the despot and keep those other things, but Bush's team wanted to go full free market Mousketeer, which may have killed more people than the insurgency, and left a country filled with sectarian politics and sectarian violence.

US invasion ruined the country, just as it ruined Afghanistan, and created the killing fields in Cambodia, and the open slave markets in Libya, and the continuing carnage in Yemen.

Until the people that makes these decision are subjected to retributive justice, the arrogance and criminality will continue.

28 May 2023

A Petri Dish for Sociopaths

I am referring, of course, to the Ivy League, which creates folks like Emily Oster (graduated from Harvard, faculty at Brown).

She caught a lot of flack, first for suggesting that we should not sent anti-retroviral drugs to treat AIDS in Africa because it was not economically while cherry-picking data to justify this, and her creation of a whole apparatus to get kids back to school because, "Kids don't get Covid," ignoring dead teachers, and when it proved that Covid kills kids too, she moved to social and educational consequences.

To the degree that she has contributed to an environment where the, "Everyone should get Covid," nuts have prevailed in the public discourse, she bears a direct responsibility for more than a million excess deaths in the United States, and more than 20 million deaths worldwide, she should be criticized for her sacrifice of those people on the alter of expedience.

Well, it would be, except for the fact that she comes from the right family, which means that criticism of her is worse than anything, as exemplified by an article titled, "Might “Vitriolic Attacks” Against Emily Oster Rival COVID’s Carnage?."

So, basically, any sort of criticism, or even worse consequences, for the elites is worse than the Holocaust.

Ignore the deaths, or the evidence that Covid causes long term health problems and cognitive deficits in both children and adults, the real injustice here is people calling Emily Oster out on various social media.

Don't worry about Ms. Oster in any case, she is doing fine, and selling all natural drinks for kids with Michelle Obama.

22 September 2020

They Say over 200,000. I Think That It Is over ¼ Million


Excess Deaths is the Gold Standard Here

So, the official death toll from Covid-19 crosses the 200,000 mark. 

The reason that I think that this number is low is that I have looked at the CDC's excess death figures, and the range there is between 201,917 and 262,877, only the death numbers can be 6-8 weeks late, and these figures only go to the week ending September 5, and deaths have been running at about 10,000 a week. 

Given that we are now entering the busy season for viral spreading, more indoor activity and lowering humidity in those spaces, I think that ½ million dead is not outside of the realm of possibility by year's end.

31 May 2020

The Impact of Police Unions

I came across a fascinating Twitter thread about the effect of police unions upon on law enforcement.

The study is preliminary, and the author is very clear on this, but the results are striking.

Police unionization has increased pay and benefits, no big surprise there, and a slight decline in police employment, which might correlate with the increase in the cost, which is also not a surprise.

The big take away is that there is a substantial increase in the lethality of law enforcement, with the death toll of minorities accounting for the bulk of the increase.

The number (admittedly preliminary) is stunning, "We find a substantial increase in police killings of civilians over the medium to long run (likely after unions are established) with an additional 0.026 to 0.029 civilians killed in a county each year of whom the overwhelming majority are non-white."

Given that there are (Googling furiously) 3,143 county equivalents in the United States, this means that we would see about 82 extra deaths a year, and over the past 40 years, this would be more than 3200 excess deaths.

The obvious conclusion is that the decrease in accountability of police officers has resulted in increased violence and police racism, though as is frequently stated, correlation is not causation.

Additionally, court rulings over the past 50+ years have had the effect of reducing police accountability for the use of force as well, so teasing out the effects specific reductions of accountability would be difficult.

The obvious take-away though is that we need greater accountability for our police forces.

02 May 2024

Good Point

There should be no amnesty, as was called for by the self-serving and perfidious Emily Oster, for medical and other professionals who were directly responsible for the unnecessary deaths of tens of millions of people as a result of the Covid pandemic.

People who advocated for a herd immunity scheme in which they knew that at a minimum hundreds of thousands of people would die, should be shunned, and not made pundits:

I can’t stop thinking about the essay No, Young Adults Should Not Live in Fear from Coronavirus by Drs. John Mandrola and Andrew Foy, two so-called “medical conservatives”. It was written on December 29th, 2020 in response to a research letter titled All-Cause Excess Mortality and COVID-19–Related Mortality Among US Adults Aged 25-44 Years, March-July 2020, which found that 4,535 COVID deaths were recorded among young adults during the pandemic’s first 5-months.

Many people were sad that 4,535 young people had died from COVID in such a short time, especially considering there had been just 4.49 million confirmed cases of COVID by the end of July 2020.

These “medical conservatives”, however, were unperturbed by thousands of dead young people. They castigated those who were concerned, decrying their “fearsome messaging.” “The infection fatality rate for young adults is quite low,” they said reassuringly. They sought to numb their readers by encouraging them to focus on the tens of millions of young adults who hadn’t died of COVID, while ignoring that the vast majority of them had yet to contract it. They wrote:
We offer four reasons why this study and OpEd do not support the claim that young adults should live in fear from the virus…

An excess of 12,000 deaths sounds bad, but Professor Don Boudreaux, from George Mason University, has noted that there are nearly 88 million people in this age group. Thus, the individual risk for a person this age is found by dividing 4,560 (the number dead from COVID19 in this study) by 88 million. This equates to a 0.0052% risk of dying from COVID19.

 

Of course, anything that kills young people can be made to sound trivial by dividing it by 88 million. The individual risk of dying at all is low for young people.

………

However, despite knowing that COVID killed 4,535 young adults in just 5-months and that only a relatively small percentage had been infected, these doctors told them their “fear of death” was misplaced. Moreover, they chose to convey this incautious message at the start of the pandemic’s deadliest wave- COVID killed 95,000 Americans in January 2021- and two months earlier, a CDC report found that infections in young people invariably spill out into the wider community. It found:

Younger adults likely contribute to community transmission of COVID-19. Across the southern United States in June 2020, increases in percentage of positive SARS-CoV-2 test results among adults aged 20–39 years preceded increases among those aged ≥60 years by 4–15 days.

………

Of course, all this was reflects what actually happened. There would have been many more such tragedies had hundreds of millions of young people, none of whom were vaccinated in December 2020, lived with zero fear of COVID, as “medical conservatives” instructed them.

………

Yet, for some inexplicable reason, these doctors- and there are many like them- feel perfectly entitled to pontificate about risks that fall well short of their own threshold of concern. Incredibly, the same doctor who wrote No, Young Adults Should Not Live in Fear from Coronavirus also wrote an error-filled article titled Vaccine-Induced Myocarditis Concerns Demand Respect, just 6-months later. He wanted his readers to “respect” the thing that wouldn’t kill them, but not to “fear” the thing that might.

………

However, it seems to me that once a doctor has minimized literal death for young people, they’ve forfeited their right to be taken seriously when they sanctimoniously demand we “respect” a rare, usually mild vaccine-side effect. Indeed, once a doctor has minimized a disease that killed 45,000 young people and seriously injured many more, they’ve forfeited their right to be taken seriously when they opine on any topic less consequential than this.

They have proven themselves to be unreliable and malicious.

Their opinions on public health should be given no more consideration than those of a rabid dog on quantum mechanics.

04 August 2025

If Someone Claims that Sweden was a Covid Success Story

They are an idiot, or a liar, or both.

Further conversation is unwarranted.

In truth the Swedish experience was catastrophic:

Over the past several months, a conventional wisdom has been solidifying in certain centrist and liberal quarters that the controls imposed during the COVID-19 pandemic Went Too Far. This idea has crystallized in a book by two Princeton political scientists, Frances Lee and Stephen Macedo—notably not epidemiologists, or virologists, or public-health experts—called In COVID’s Wake: How Our Politics Failed Us. The authors have gotten a respectable hearing from PBS, Jake Tapper, and, of course, The Daily podcast from The New York Times.

The podcast If Books Could Kill recently did a deep-dive debunking of this book, but I want to focus on its treatment of Sweden because of how it’s become a synecdoche for the whole argument. In the Financial Times, the normally level-headed Ed Luce recently cited the Swedish example: “Everyone could agree back then that otherwise liberal Sweden was foolish to take the herd immunity route. That Sweden ended up with one of the lowest mortality rates in Europe has not been similarly highlighted.” The book “should be compulsory reading across the spectrum. That it has not been reviewed by most major newspapers is troubling,” he added. 

………

What’s more, the U.K. figures are provisional, and actual studies have very different numbers. A study in The Lancet by Pizzato et al. found that Sweden’s excess mortality rate was 7.2 percent in 2020—worse than Germany or Greece—and only -0.2 percent in 2021.

Whatever the correct figure is, a lot of Sweden’s mortality drop in 2021 almost certainly was just moving deaths around. For instance, dementia deaths dropped by a lot in 2021-2022, and as a study in the European Journal of Epidemiology notes, “This might reflect that many frail individuals with dementia died prematurely in 2020, hence reducing the population of individuals with dementia who would be at risk of dying in 2021 and 2022.” Seeing a drop in dementia deaths because those individuals were already dead from the government letting COVID run wild in nursing homes is not anything to celebrate.

The lockdown-focused story about mortality is also misleading when it comes to 2022. Prior to that year, the other Nordics were doing far better than Sweden—but they got hammered by the omicron variant, while Sweden did not, which is why it ended up with the best overall mortality rate through 2023, per the Lancet study. Why? It wasn’t immunity from prior infections, as a study in Frontiers in Immunology argues persuasively, but rather that Sweden did its rollout of booster shots far faster than the other Nordics. Ironically, it was swift action by the Swedish public-health bureaucracy, not failing to lock down two years previously, that saved lives. It is simply not true that “interventions seemed to do little if any good beyond delaying the inevitable” or that “the stringency of pandemic restrictions made little evident difference for countries’ overall Covid mortality,” as the authors argue. If Sweden had locked down in the critical early months of the pandemic as its neighbors did, a great many of those 2020 deaths could have been avoided through vaccination and not crushing the hospitals.

While the Danny DeVito — Billy Crystal movie was a good movie, and surprisingly sweet, Throw Momma from the Train is not a good strategy for public health professionals.

31 January 2024

Ecch (Tweet) of the Day

You can see the data set that he uses for the graph here.

Covid isn't over, and it won't be over until the polity decides to take it seriously, and stop worrying about the economic impact.

The truth is that between excess deaths, and long Covid disability, the economic impacts are far less than actually confronting the pandemic.

24 March 2026

Pshaw!

Researchers at Boston University have combed through the death certificates, and Covid deaths were severely undercounted during the height of the pandemic.

Thank-you Captain Obvious. 

This was clear from the most cursory examination of excess death data.

The covid-19 pandemic was perhaps the greatest natural disaster to befall America and the world in modern times. Research out today, however, indicates that we’re still underselling just how deadly it truly was.

Researchers at Boston University and others examined national death certificate data collected in the first two years of the pandemic. They estimated that the official tally missed nearly 20% of covid-related fatalities between 2020 and 2021, amounting to 155,536 uncounted deaths. These missing cases were more common among minority and disadvantaged communities, likely reflecting longstanding disparities in how deaths are investigated in the country, the researchers say.

This sh$# ain't rocket science.

Both the death toll and the bad statistics are a natural consequence of having a public health establishment opposed to the idea of public health.

27 July 2020

Busy Day for the 'Rona?

In major league baseball Marlins have canceled the home opener over a a Coronavirus outbreak on their team while the Phillies Yankees game has been postponed.

In the NFL, the Minnesota Vikings have announced that their Infection Control Officer has tested positive for Covid-19. (Not a joke)

Trump's National Security Advisor Robert O’Brien has tested positive for the virus.

Also, total reported Covid-19 deaths are approaching 150,000, though the CDC excess death data indicates at least 170,000 pandemic related deaths.  (The last 6-8 weeks are incomplete)