Americans Used to Work in Meatpacking

When one looks at the phrase, "Jobs Americans Won't Do," which is frequently used to justify both a lax policy on legal immigration, and salutary neglect toward illegal aliens.

One of the jobs that is supposed to be in this category is working in meat packing.

Dean Baker makes the point that his is inaccurate and ahistorical.

There were many Americans who worked in meat packing, and made a decent living from doing so, until engage in a decades long program of pushing down wages in the industry, which involved aggressive pursuit of undocumented workers and a vicious campaign against the unions.

The idea that there are jobs that Americans won't do is a myth.

When someone says that, they mean that there are jobs that Americans won't do if you have sh%$ty wages and benefits.