Showing posts sorted by relevance for query front running goldman. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query front running goldman. Sort by date Show all posts

01 November 2010

Prosecution Doing Back-Flips For Goldman Sachs in High Frequency Trading Trial

If there was any doubt that the federal prosecutors in New York prosecuting Sergey Aleynikov for theft of trade secrets weren't in Goldman Sach's Pocket, those doubts have been allayed:
Goldman Sachs Group Inc. has always closely guarded the secrets of its lucrative high-speed trading system. Now the securities firm is getting a help from an unusual source: federal prosecutors.

Federal prosecutors in Manhattan this week asked a federal district judge to seal the courtroom at the forthcoming trial of a former Goldman computer programmer accused of stealing the firm's computer code. The move was a formal request to empty the courtroom of the general public when details of Goldman's trade secrets are being discussed. The trial is set to start to late November.

Prosecutors also asked that any documents related to Goldman's trading strategies remain under seal.

Such requests are common when proprietary corporate information could be exposed in a trial, lawyers say. This case is unusual in that it involves secrets about a potentially lucrative trading system, rather than, say, ingredients in a soda formula.
What is also unusual is that this code is almost certainly obsolete, and almost certainly has no value to a competitor.

The software almost certainly has to be updated regularly, probably monthly, possibly weekly, which means that the algorithms and code are almost certainly obsolete, but still they want the court sealed.

This is not about protecting trade secrets, this is about concerns by the vampire squid* that if the details on how they conducted business came out, they would have people calling for their scalps for front-running the markets.

Basically, Goldman, and the prosecutors, are trying to conceal activity by Goldman that is either illegal, or would lead to changes in regulations that would make it so if the details came out.

My earlier posts on this are here.

*Alas, I cannot claim credit for the bon mot describing Goldman Sachs as a, "great vampire squid wrapped around the face of humanity, relentlessly jamming its blood funnel into anything that smells like money." This was coined by the great Matt Taibbi, in his article on the massive criminal conspiracy investment firm, The Great American Bubble Machine.

08 July 2009

Is Goldman Sachs Running a Scam Right out of The Sting?

Yes, we now have a case of what appears to be industrial espionage, or perhaps geeky security breaches, this is once more pulling back a part of the masque from that great vampire squid wrapped around the face of humanity*, Goldman Sachs.

Specifically, a former programmer at Goldman Sachs, one Sergey Aleynikov, is alleged to have stolen the proprietary program trading software that they use and stored it on a server somewhere in Germany. (Also here and here)

What is interesting is what this software actually does:
The platform is one of the things that apparently gives Goldman a leg-up over the competition when it comes to rapid-fire trading of stocks and commodities. Federal authorities say the platform quickly processes rapid developments in the markets and uses top secret mathematical formulas to allow the firm to make highly-profitable automated trades.
Or as is noted in the criminal complaint:
The Financial Institution has devoted substantial resources to developing and maintaining a computer platform that allows the Financial Institution to engage in sophisticated high-speed, and high-volume trades on various stock and commodities markets. Among other things, the platform is capable of quickly obtaining and processing information regarding rapid developments in these markets.
So basically, we have high speed software to execute computer driven trades in response to market fluctuations, to the tune of about 60% of all of these trades, about $100 million a day,

We also have this tidbit from the prosecutor, "The bank has raised the possibility that there is a danger that somebody who knew how to use this program could use it to manipulate markets in unfair ways."

The reality here is that it is being used to manipulate markets in unfair ways, by Goldman Sachs.

Vet74 at Daily Kos explains in a fairly technical way, but basically, this is the scam within a scam from the Paul Newman/Robert Redford movie The Sting, where the man they are cheating, murderous gangster Doyle Lonnegan, believes that they are delaying the ticker tape of race results so as to place bets on horses that have already won.

When they note that the software, "quickly processes rapid developments in the markets," what they really mean is that this software can pick up on large orders in process, and get their orders in ahead of those orders already in process, and generate profits.

If this were a human transaction, with the agent doing it to a client, it would be called front-running, and it would be a felony.

I'm pretty sure that Goldman does not want everything to come out in court, because, even if it's legal, the revelations would likely lead to calls for additional regulatory reform.

They just want this gut to cop a plea, extract some sort of non-disclosure agreement, and then make him disappear.

You can tell this, because they are playing some serious hardball here.

They discovered the loss of the code some time in mid June, but held off on notifying authorities until July 1, pretty much guaranteeing that the arrest, and setting of bail would take place over the holiday, and he would have to spend the weekend in jail.

He is out on bail now, but I expect a plea, or a convenient suicide, because the exposure in open court of what amounts to a massive, pervasive, and thoroughly corrupt insider trading scheme is something that the squids* will find unacceptable.

Then again, I am a bit tinfoil hat on such things.

*Alas, I cannot claim credit for this bon mot, it was coined by the great Matt Taibbi, in his article on the massive criminal conspiracy investment firm, The Great American Bubble Machine.

06 July 2015

After 6 Years of Prosecutorial Excess on Behalf of the Vampire Squid, We Finally See Aleynikov's Total Exoneration

After multiple prosecutions, by multiple prosecutors, at the behest of Goldman Sachs, Sergey Aleynikov is a free man, for a while, at least:
Kevin H. Marino pumped his fist in the air in celebration. Then Mr. Marino, a New Jersey lawyer with a linebacker’s build, turned to his longtime client, Sergey Aleynikov, and gave Mr. Aleynikov, a former Goldman Sachs programmer, a bear hug and a hearty pat on the back.

Just moments earlier, a clerk in State Supreme Court in Manhattan had given Mr. Marino a copy of the judicial ruling that overturned Mr. Aleynikov’s conviction on a charge that he stole confidential computer code for Goldman Sachs’s high-speed trading business.

The clerk, saving Mr. Marino from having to thumb through the 72 pages to learn what Justice Daniel P. Conviser had ruled, simply whispered congratulations to the lawyer. For Mr. Aleynikov, 45, and Mr. Marino, it appeared to be the end of a six-year legal odyssey through the federal and state court systems in New York.

But the celebration may not last long. State prosecutors in Manhattan have already indicated they may appeal the decision issued Monday, which threw out a jury’s verdict.

Once before, Mr. Aleynikov had believed he was in the clear, when a federal appeals court overturned his conviction under a federal corporate espionage law in 2012. The appellate court ruled that federal prosecutors in Manhattan had misapplied the law, and it ordered Mr. Aleynikov to be immediately released from a federal prison.

Less than a year later, however, Mr. Aleynikov was back in court defending himself, after state prosecutors in Manhattan charged him with violating state computer-theft-related laws.

Now Justice Conviser — much like the federal appellate court before him — ruled that the decades-old state law that Mr. Aleynikov was convicted of violating did not apply to the accusations against him.

………

But Mr. Marino was at no loss for words in criticizing Goldman.

“Goldman Sachs is powerful enough to provoke two failed criminal prosecutions to settle a private score,” Mr. Marino said. “Goldman Sachs has also spent millions in shareholder dollars to evade their obligation to pay Mr. Aleynikov’s legal fees for winning two criminal cases.”
I rather expect Vance to appeal, since the Manhattan district attorney is clearly bought and paid for by Wall Street.

At the time, I was hoping that this would turn over the rock that is the illegal front running high frequency trading conducting by the biggest brokerage firms, but the prosecutors were determined to keep that covered up, and to continue to avoid prosecutions that might bot reveal Goldman's skullduggery, and follow up with prosecutions grounded in bizarre legal theories.

Background here.

27 February 2010

This is a Case to Watch

Sergey Aleynikov, a senior programmer for Goldman Sach's high frequency trading software, has been indicted for software theft.

It's alleged that he took the software, and sent copies of it to a server in Germany.

This case is odd.

First, the entire high frequency trading thing smells of corruption: The idea is that by having servers colocated in the market, you pick up a few milliseconds speed, and so can execute trades between when someone else requests a buy, and when their transaction is actually executed.

To my, admittedly untrained, gut this sounds identical to front-running, which is illegal.

Additionally, the twists and turns of the trial, where Aleynikov's lawyers made some fairly routing requests for things like his personnel file to show that he was not a disgruntled employee, had the squid's* lawyers seriously freaking out, and suggesting that charges should be dropped.

I think that there are some very real bits of corruption that might be uncovered in the trial, though the prosecution, defense, and judge might very well find a way to suppress that, because, after all, it's Goldman Sachs, and rule number 1 of Goldman Sachs is that Goldman Sachs has friends in high places, so it always gets what it wants.

My prior posts are here.

*Alas, I cannot claim credit for the bon mot describing Goldman Sachs as a, "great vampire squid wrapped around the face of humanity, relentlessly jamming its blood funnel into anything that smells like money." This was coined by the great Matt Taibbi, in his article on the massive criminal conspiracy investment firm, The Great American Bubble Machine.

13 July 2009

Wanker of the Day

Megan McArdle (Note that this is a link to Barry Ritholtz, not the McArdle article, because friends don't give friends links to Randroids).

You see, she's one of those people who read "Atlas Shrugged" in high school (I read the "Virtue of Selfishness, and hated every poorly crafted juvenile word), and never got over it. (She used to blog under the pseudonym "Jane Gault")

She says that Matt Taibbi is wrong when he fingers Goldman Sachs as a politically connected octopus (OK, "that great vampire squid wrapped around the face of humanity,"* Goldman Sachs.) that was front and center in gaming and profiting from the regulatory arbitrage and fraud that enriched their principals, and beggared the rest of us, "for the simple reason that no one person or even one group is powerful enough to take down a whole system."

What's at the core of this is Randroid objectivist bullsh$#. The markets, you see, are brilliant, and so no one person, nor one organization, can game them.†

It's the same thing that led Alan Greenspan to tell Brooksley Born that, "Wasn't a need for a law against fraud because if a floor broker was committing fraud, the customer would figure it out and stop doing business with him."

You see markets, and all there participants are the epitome of capitalist savvy, and as such, they would never be unaware of others engaging in unsafe activities for their own benefits, and so the only explanation of failure must be collective, so it's everyone's fault, particularly that lay-about mom working 60 hours a week at minimum wage, which makes it no one's fault.

I hope she has someone to cut her meat for her, because I think that the safe operation of a steak knife is beyond her.

*Alas, I cannot claim credit for this bon mot, it was coined by the great Matt Taibbi, in his article on the massive criminal conspiracy investment firm, The Great American Bubble Machine.
†This is despite the fact that the currently unraveling software theft case shows that Goldman Sachs has been front-running the entire stock market.

17 February 2012

Sergey Aleynikov Freed

You may recall that he was convicted under the Economic Espionage Act for downloading some high frequency trading software from Goldman Sachs, where he worked.

Apparently, the judge in the trial completely bought into the prosecutions expansion of the law, intended to prosecute people for selling military secrets to the Chinese, to this case, and the appellate court came down hard on the judge. They did not just remand this back to the lower court, they ordered the lower court to enter a judgement of acquittal.

Felix Salmon explains why whole case was such an outrage:
The secrets at defense contractors, of course, are secret for reasons of national security. The secrets at investment banks and hedge funds, by contrast, are secret purely for reasons of profit: they reckon that if they have some clever algorithm which nobody else has, then that makes it easier for them to profit from it. Which is why it was always a stretch for the government to use the EEA to prosecute Aleynikov — indeed, it is why it was always a stretch for Aleynikov to be criminally prosecuted at all. Goldman could have brought a civil case against him, but instead they got their wholly-owned subsidiary, the U.S. government, to come down on him so hard that he ended up with an eight-year sentence. Violent felons frequently get less.

The forthcoming decision from the Second Circuit is likely to be a doozy; I’m told that the judges shredded the prosecutors during the oral hearing. And certainly their decision to enter a judgment of acquittal, rather than any kind of retrial, is a strong indication that they handed down this order with extreme prejudice against prosecutorial overreach.
(emphasis mine)

This has been a lose-lose for the Vampire Squid. They looked like bullies, they brought a lot of attention to the bit of front-running that is high frequency trading, and they have now lost the case.

That being said, I don't expect Goldman, or the prosecutors, to give up just yet.

Background here.

13 August 2009

Something Smells Very Fishy Here

Remember that guy who allegedly stole Goldman Sach's proprietary high speed trading software? You know, the stuff that ran on their co-located servers in the exchanges, and so as to engage in front-running the entire market?

Well, it looks like there is a no jail time deal for Sergey Aleynikov in the offing about this.

Goldman Sachs has apparently folded like a bunch of overcooked broccoli, after the defense got a ruling saying that said that they were to be given access to all relevant personnel records.

So, Goldman Sachs, that great vampire squid wrapped around the face of humanity,* the folks who think, probably correctly, that they own the United States of America, acted like a prison bitch when confronted with the possibility of his reviewing his own personnel file???

Something is very wrong here.

What on earth are they hiding?

FWIW, any tips received will be kept in strictest confidence.

*Alas, I cannot claim credit for this bon mot, it was coined by the great Matt Taibbi, in his article on the massive criminal conspiracy investment firm, The Great American Bubble Machine.

01 December 2010

Well, This is a Surprise

In the latest twist to the legal travails of Sergey Aleynikov, who is accused of theft of Goldman-Sach's illegal market front-running high frequency trading software is now arguing that the code in question was open source, so there was no theft:
Sergey Aleynikov, who is accused of stealing Goldman Sachs’ source code used in high-frequency trading, argued that he was standing up to the investment bank’s proprietary claims on open-source code, not trying to steal private codes to use at a competing trading firm.

Mr Aleynikov, a former computer programmer at the bank, is accused of downloading proprietary code related to high-speed trading systems in June 2009 for use at a new job at a competing firm.
While this statement may actually be true, it does strike me as a rather low percentage defense.

Unfortunately, it also implies that we will not be getting any details on how the Vampire Squid and its Wall Street co-conspirators might actually be gaming the system with their co-located high speed trading systems during the trial.

13 October 2022

Cue the World's Smallest Violin

It appears that SEC Chairman Gary Gensler is giving Wall Street a sad because he wants them to stop defrauding the rest of us. 

Boo f%$#ing hoo:

Wall Street’s top regulator is pursuing the biggest overhaul of the $51 trillion U.S. stock market in two decades. First he’ll have to fend off a major industry resistance campaign.

Securities and Exchange Commission Chair Gary Gensler — a former Goldman Sachs partner turned progressive icon — is set to launch a regulatory broadside in the coming weeks against brokerage and trading giants including Charles Schwab, Robinhood and GOP megadonor Ken Griffin’s Citadel Securities, according to interviews with more than a dozen executives, lawmakers, regulators and investor advocates.

So, this sounds like regulations against payment for order flow, which is basically front-running (illegal) re-labeled.

Interesting fact:  This was invented by Bernie Madoff, yes, THAT Bernie Madoff.

The rules that Gensler is spearheading would revamp the stock market’s plumbing, partly in response to the 2021 meme stock saga in which Robinhood and other brokerages attracted scrutiny after they were overwhelmed by trading in shares of companies such as GameStop and AMC. Gensler, who has held leading regulatory roles in the Biden and Obama administrations, has questioned whether investors are operating in an environment that is “as fair and competitive as possible.” He is expected to crack down on the complex web of payments and fees that exchanges, brokerages and trading firms share when processing investors’ stock trades.

While the proposals have yet to be released, industry executives have already begun talking about suing the SEC over the plans. And a growing number of Hill Democrats are urging Gensler to proceed with caution, signaling a potentially treacherous political road ahead even among members of his own party — one that will become even more fraught if Republican critics gain a majority in Congress.

“We have to be careful not to throw the baby out with the bathwater,” Rep. Ritchie Torres, a New York Democrat on the House Financial Services Committee, said in an interview.
Torres gets the largest proportion of his campaign money from finance, with real-estate, which is hand in hand with finance, particularly in New York, a close second.

Mandy Rice-Davies applies.

………

At issue for Gensler is ultimately a series of long-held concerns from investor advocates and progressives that the current market is not built for everyday people and institutional investors such as pension funds — but rather for Wall Street intermediaries.

The SEC chief has talked about half a dozen possible reforms. Among them are changes to the way stock trades are priced on exchanges like NYSE and Nasdaq, which Gensler has said are not on a level playing field with other trading venues that operate with more regulatory flexibility and less transparency. Only about half of all trading in the market today occurs on stock exchanges, with the rest taking place through banks and brokerages running private markets and handling the trades themselves. Gensler has also discussed more disclosures around how brokers execute clients’ orders, changes to what constitutes the best price in the market and ways to move more trading to public exchanges.

………

The question is whether the Gensler-led SEC will be able to enact the proposals in the face of widespread backlash.
Bank robbers hat vault doors and armed guards, and the, "Widespread Backlash," here is a few thousand people who get rich cheating the rest of us.
Some of the firms that have the most to lose — the wholesalers and brokerages responsible for how and where individual investors’ trades occur — have already started to lay the groundwork for lawsuits, including by amassing data to refute the SEC’s economic case for the changes.
Of course they are.  I'm sure that they are already figuring how to get this before a judge who will swallow the sh%$ that they are peddling.
………

“You don’t want to do a massive restructuring of how things work without some feeling of how it’s going to work,” said Rep. Bill Foster (D-Ill.), a House Financial Services Committee member who is urging the SEC to first use a pilot program before introducing changes to the broader market.
An excuse to do nothing, from a member New Democrat Coalition, over $½ million from the finance, insurance and real estate sectors.
………

“The conflicts of interest that have evolved have already become very ingrained and central to intermediaries’ business models,” said Tyler Gellasch, a former SEC official who now runs the Healthy Markets Association, an investor advocacy group that has been calling for many of the changes Gensler is expected to propose. “The question will really be how far is this commission going to go to protect investors?”

I think that Gensler would go pretty far.  Unfortunately the Democrats in the House and the Senate, along with other elements of the  Democratic Party establishment (There is no Democratic Party establishment) will do everything that they can to stop him.

10 July 2009

The Mainstream Media Notices that Goldman Sachs is Front-Running*

The entire software caper, and the implication that Goldman Sachs is using software tricks to conduct its computerized trades a few milliseconds before everyone else has hit Bloomberg News.

Nothing to see here, move along.

*Background here.

06 September 2010

Sergey Aleynikov Gets One Count Dismissed

He is accused of stealing Goldman Sachs' proprietary high frequency trading software, but one of the three counts against him, for unauthorized computer access, has been dismissed.

I've always maintained that HFT is actually illegal front-running, or at least it was illegal before Treasury Secretary Robert "Why am I not in jail?" Rubin got his hands on the regulatory regime, and as such, I have always wondered if there was a cover-up of some kind, seeing as how the prosecutors have admitted that this code could be used to manipulate the markets.

A twist in the case that I was unaware of was that Sergey is not the only one the Feds are going after on this, as, "Two months after Aleynikov's indictment, prosecutors charged former Societe Generale trader Samarth Agrawal with stealing computer code used in high-frequency proprietary trading in the French bank's New York office."

I am beginning to think that there is an official policy of allowing "systemically important" banks to skim profits from the markets in order to bolster balance sheets that are far shakier than has been revealed, but they want to keep this technology out of the hands of the small fry, because it would make the flash crash look like a weenie roast if too many people got their hands on this technology.

Background here

22 August 2013

Linkage

17 August 2009

What's the Word For This???? Oh....Right....Regulation

Put this down to "Elections can mean something."

It looks like the case of Goldman Sachs's allegedly purloined high speed trading software, aka "Flash Trading", which a number of observers, myself included, have noted sounds a lot like front-running the entire stock market, now appears to be creating some regulatory push-back.

Basically, this allowed high speed servers co-located with the markets to execute trades in the milliseconds between when other trades are initiated, and when they are completed.

First, as a result of questions raised by Senator Charles Schumer, both Nasdaq and Bats Global Markets have decided to stop allowing brokerages to execute trades in this manner on their exchanges.

The Financial Times notes that this sort of automated trading currently accounts for over ½ of all US stock trades.

Additionally, it appears that the S.E.C. is looking at restricting the process.

Here is a simple solution: Require that any trading done by computers be delayed by at least 15 minutes from initiation to execution.

It also looks like the S.E.C will crack down on "naked" short sales, where an investor sells shares he does not have, as opposed to borrowing shares to sell, which they would purchase and return at a later date.

On the commodities side of the equation, the FTC is issuing new rules to restrict the ability of traders to manipulate the markets.

I'm wondering when the Giethner/Summers shoe will drop, and they will push for elimination of these regulations, because it makes US markets "less competitive."

24 July 2009

It's a Half Step

Barack Obama is now proposing a tax on "risky" financial transactions.

The problem here is two fold:
  • Many of the risky financial transactions were there to skirt regulations, and this just creates another incentive for people to do this again.
  • Many of the problems with our markets come from people who attempt to generate minuscule profits across thousands, or millions, of trades, Goldman Sachs front-running the entire US stock market comes to mind.
The solution to fixing this is to make rapid-fire low margin speculation unprofitable, and the way to do this is to to tax all financial transactions at something like ¼-½%.

For the investor, this is an infinitesimal cost of doing business, but it puts the rampant speculator out of business.

It eliminates regulatory arbitrage, and could go a long way toward paying for health care reform.

07 December 2009

Ass Covering: Secretary of the Treasury Edition

So, now that there are an increasing number of people calling for his scalp, Timothy "Eddie Haskell" Geithner is talking tough about the banks:
Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner disputed claims by Goldman Sachs Group Inc. executives that the bank could have survived the financial crisis without government help and said it and other Wall Street firms should show some restraint in handing out bonuses this year.

“It is very important that we change the way these executives are paid, the form of compensation, this year,” Geithner said in an interview yesterday for Bloomberg Television’s “Political Capital with Al Hunt,” which is being aired throughout the weekend. “We have to end that era of irresponsibly high bonuses.”
So, the guy who, until now, said very little about bank pay, and:
Now he's saying that none of the banks were solvent, and that they all survived only through government largess, and that they are overpaying their staff.

This is all about the calls to can him getting louder, not any "road to Damascus" moment.

11 March 2014

We Now Get the Chance to See How Much Corruption Barack Obama will Tolerate in the State Security Apparatus

We have know that the President tolerated it when Director of National Intelligence James Clapper blatantly and unashamedly lied to Congress, but this is a much bigger deal.

Dianne Feinstein* just took to the floor of the Senate and accused the CIA of obstructing a senate investigation and attempting to intimidate the Senate Intelligence Committee Staff:
The chairwoman of the Senate intelligence committee, Dianne Feinstein, on Tuesday accused the Central Intelligence Agency of a catalogue of cover-ups, intimidation and smears aimed at investigators probing its role in an “un-American and brutal” programme of post-9/11 detention and interrogation.

In a bombshell statement on the floor of the US Senate, Feinstein, normally an administration loyalist, accused the CIA of potentially violating the US constitution and of criminal activity in its attempts to obstruct her committee’s investigations into the agency’s use of torture. She described the crisis as a “defining moment” for political oversight of the US intelligence service.

Her unprecedented public assault on the CIA represented an intensification of the row between the committee and the agency over a still-secret report on the torture of terrorist suspects after 9/11.

Feinstein, who said she was making her statement “reluctantly”, confirmed recent reports that CIA officials had been accused of monitoring computer networks used by Senate staff investigators. Going further than previously, she referred openly to recent attempts by the CIA to remove documents from the network detailing evidence of torture that would incriminate intelligence officers.

She also alleged that anonymous CIA officials were effectively conducting a smear campaign in the media to discredit and “intimidate” Senate staff by suggesting they had hacked into the agency’s computers to obtain a separate, critical internal report on the detention and interrogation programme.
While it is tempting to focus on the obvious irony of Feinstein's outrage in the face of her previous full throated support of intellligence excesses, as Edward Snowden does, this is a much bigger issue.

If what Feinstein alleges is true, and I am inclined to believe it because it is a statement against her normal interests, which is as a CIA fanboi, it lends credibility.

Going over her speech, here is what she presents:
  • The Senate Intelligence Committee demanded that all relevant documents be turned over to them so that they might be able to investigate the CIA's torture program.
  • The CIA balked, and so the committee and then CIA Director Leon Panetta negotiated an arrangement whereby the staff would access these documents at a CIA secured facility.  Here is the relevant quote:
Per an exchange of letters in 2009, then-Vice Chairman Bond, then-Director Panetta, and I agreed in an exchange of letters that the CIA was to provide a “stand-alone computer system” with a “network drive” “segregated from CIA networks” for the committee that would only be accessed by information technology personnel at the CIA—who would “not be permitted to” “share information from the system with other [CIA] personnel, except as otherwise authorized by the committee.”
  • Unsurprisingly, the CIA provided the documents without any sort of index or any search facility, though one was later added at Senate requests
  • It was this computer system that the CIA searched, in contravention of their agreement.
  • The CIA also insisted on additional multiple level levels of review that were not a part of the agreement.
  • When the staff found something relevant, they would save it to disk at the securely located computer, or print it out.
  • The staff found that documents that they had flagged as important were disappearing.
  • The CIA denied this, then blamed the IT staffers, and finally claimed that this was ordered by the White House, who denied this, and ordered the CIA to cooperate, "The matter was resolved with a renewed commitment from the White House Counsel, and the CIA, that there would be no further unauthorized access to the committee’s network or removal of access to CIA documents already provided to the committee."
  • In 2010, the staff found a draft of the "Internal Panetta Review," an internal review that Panetta commissioned by on torture that demolished the official CIA response to the (as yet unreleased) Senate report.  It specifically contradicted the official report in a number of ways, most notably:
    • The practices were far more brutal that officially revealed.
    • There was no meaningful intelligence derived from torture
  • Because of the importance of the document, it mirrored the Senate Committee conclusions, the staff printed it out for safe keeping, and placed it in the secure safe in the Senate Intelligence Committee Offices.  This was done in accordance with the document handling procedures agreed between the CIA and Intel Committee.
  • The CIA then disappeared the Panetta report from the Senate staffers computers.
  • The CIA has still refused to supply the Panetta Review to the Senate.
  • On January 15, 2014, "CIA personnel had conducted a “search”—that was John Brennan’s word—of the committee computers at the offsite facility. This search involved not only a search of documents provided to the committee by the CIA, but also a search of the ”stand alone” and “walled-off” committee network drive containing the committee’s own internal work product and communications."
    • Note that even if this does not qualify as obstructing a Congressional investigation (I think that it does), it is a violation of the law for the CIA to conduct surveillance in the US   If they needed to search the computers (assuming that Congressional immunity does not apply) they would have to go the the FBI. (Which they must have hated)
  • The CIA has refused to provide additional details on the scope of the search, which, "May also have violated the Fourth Amendment, the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, as well as Executive Order 12333, which prohibits the CIA from conducting domestic searches or surveillance."
  • The CIA's Inspector General looked at the searches done by the CIA, and concluded that they needed to be investigated criminally, and made a referral to the DoJ.
  • In response, the acting general counsel of the CIA made a criminal referral of the Senate staffers to the DOJ.
Here is the money quote:
I should note that for most, if not all, of the CIA’s Detention and Interrogation Program, the now acting general counsel was a lawyer in the CIA’s Counterterrorism Center—the unit within which the CIA managed and carried out this program. From mid-2004 until the official termination of the detention and interrogation program in January 2009, he was the unit’s chief lawyer. He is mentioned by name more than 1,600 times in our study.

And now this individual is sending a crimes report to the Department of Justice on the actions of congressional staff—the same congressional staff who researched and drafted a report that details how CIA officers—including the acting general counsel himself—provided inaccurate information to the Department of Justice about the program.
(emphasis mine)

While Feinstein does not mention the counsel's name, it is public knowledge that the CIA's acting general counsel is Robert Eatinger, who among other things, Authorized the Destruction of the CIA Torture Tapes Against the Instructions of the Bush White House and the Director of National Intelligence.

The White House response is a a statement of, "Great Confidence," in CIA director John Brennan.  So Obama wants to keep this guy.

As I have said before, the worst constitutional law professor ever.

I expect further stonewalling on the part of both the CIA and the Obama administration.

What should happen is that Eatinger should be placed on leave, and his security clearance should be suspended, but I imagine that he will continue to do damage to the Constitution of the United States, and then he will retire with a full pension.

*Full disclosure, my great grandfather, Harry Goldman, and her grandfather, Sam Goldman were brothers.

Full speech follows: